Low Sugar Desserts You Can Find at the Grocery Store

low sugar dessert alternatives

We all have a love-hate relationship with sugar. We try to wean ourselves off, but it’s everywhere when you dine out or grocery shop. While we all crave the sweet euphoria of a sugar high, too much of it in your diet can lead to health problems, such as weight gain, diabetes, and heart disease. 

Fact: The American Heart Association suggests that women should have no more than 25 grams of sugar a day, while men should have a maximum of 35 grams

If you’re not already trained in reading labels, you might be shocked at how easy it is to exceed these limits (even if you think you’re eating all the right foods). For example: 

  • 1 8-oz cup of organic orange juice contains 25 grams of sugar
  • 1 nutrition bar contains 21 grams of sugar
  • 1 açaí bowl can contain up to 65 grams of sugar (depending on toppings)

But don’t worry. You can still indulge when your sweet tooth strikes. You just have to learn which low sugar desserts to look for when you’re grocery shopping.

Here are some of our favorite low sugar desserts and sweeteners that you can find at your local grocery store:

Low Sugar Desserts: Frozen Aisle

So Delicious Dipped Vanilla Bean Bars

These “no added sugar” and dairy free ice cream bars are sweetened with erythritol and stevia. They’re similar to the Haagen Dazs bars, but without all the sugar, fat, and calories.

Enlightened Ice Cream

We’ve tried several protein ice creams, and Enlightened is our clear favorite in terms of texture and flavors. While most protein-packed ice creams seem to be on the icier side, we found Enlightened to be the creamiest of them all. One serving only contains 6 grams of sugar, but adds 7 grams of protein. Win-win.

Sambazon Unsweetened Açaí Puree Packs

As mentioned before, store bought açaí bowls often contain up to 65 grams of sugar. The açaí puree used in these bowls are almost always pre-sweetened with cane sugar. With these unsweetened packs, you can make a low sugar version at home and achieve the same level of sweetness by adding stevia or monk fruit. 

Do: top it with seeds, nut butter, and berries. Don’t: add the banana if you want to keep it lower in sugar.

Low Sugar Desserts: Snack Aisle

Lily’s Peanut Butter Cups

These are the new and improved (for your health) Reese’s peanut butter cups. You won’t be getting the 24 grams of sugar in the Lily’s version, but these will satisfy that nostalgic craving nonetheless. Perfect for sneaking into a movie theater!

Catalina Crunch Cinnamon Toast

If your favorite cereal as a kid was Cinnamon Toast Crunch, you’ll love this healthier version. It’s sweetened with organic monk fruit and contains no sugar, but has a whopping 10 grams of protein and 6 grams of fiber. This would be a great breakfast for the whole family, and help keep energy levels stable due to the protein and fiber content. 

Smart Sweets

Smart Sweets created better-for-you versions of nostalgic gummies, such as sour patch kids, swedish fish, gummy bears, and my personal favorite, peach rings. These no sugar candies would also make perfect accompaniments to movie night.

Low Sugar Desserts: Bakery Aisle

NuStevia Maple Syrup

This stevia-sweetened maple-flavored syrup is the perfect condiment for weekend pancakes and waffles, and will also save you from the 53 grams of sugar in traditional maple syrups. This one might be tougher to find in grocery stores, but Lakanto maple syrup is a good and similar alternative.

Lakanto Monkfruit Sweeteners

Sometimes stevia doesn’t cut it in baking, and that’s okay. The Lakanto line of sugars and sweeteners uses a blend of monk fruit and erythritol that mimics the taste and textures of sugar like no other. It’s also a 1:1 substitute in baking, so no need to figure out tricky math conversions. 

Lily’s Chocolate Chips

We had to give Lily’s another mention here. They produce stevia-sweetened chocolate in many forms, and chocolate chips (white, milk, semi-sweet, and dark) are no exception. These are perfect in chocolate chip cookies and banana bread.

Final Thoughts: Low Sugar Desserts

The best way to monitor your sugar intake is to get in the habit of reading nutrition facts and labels. If your maximum daily allowance is 25 grams of sugar, do you really want to waste that on one serving of fruit juice? Or would you rather be able to have multiple low sugar desserts throughout the day? I’d say that’s a no-brainer.


Yes Health is a low-cost, weight loss and diabetes-prevention program committed to helping everyone live healthier, happier lives.